The
problems uniquely facing parents of boys and the young men themselves
could fill a book. Indeed, they have filled many on the market.
However,
for the purposes of this column, I have chosen to focus on just three
myths common in LDS culture that I think exacerbate the issue.
The
myth I am focusing on in this segment is one I have heard many times
in Sunday School, testimonies, and occasionally from the pulpit. It
is: “Women are just more spiritual.”
Now
perhaps I have missed the memo and this is canonized doctrine, but I
don’t think so. I think this is a myth. Every time I hear it
spouted from the pulpit or podium, I wage an internal battle.
Roll
my eyes? Or cringe? Roll my eyes or cringe? ROLL-MY-EYES-OR-CRINGE?
Sometimes
I do both.
My
first problem with this myth is that it is just not true.
My
second problem with this myth is the (often) unsaid portion of this
myth, which is “….than men.”
I
do not buy that women are naturally more spiritual than men. First,
and foremost, Jesus is a man. As is the current Prophet. As are the
apostles, mission presidents, and all the other amazing men who lead
this Church.
Do
we really think they are just flukes?
I
will grant that not every man is a potential General Authority. Of
course, nor is every women a potential member of the Relief Society
General Board. However, there are more than enough men Churchwide who
are adequately spiritual to be inspirational leaders at all levels of
Church organization.
I
suspect this is a cultural belief hailing from a different time when
the “ideal woman” was more gentle than strong, more
demure than educated, and more soft-spoken than standing up for her
convictions.
There
is nothing wrong with being gentle, demure, and soft-spoken —
but these things do not equate to more spirituality.
The
specific issues that call women and men into a lifestyle of the
“natural man” may be different, but they are equally
potent, and both men and women have to conscientiously work toward a
state that is closer to the Spirit, or “more spiritual.”
I
resent the implication that it must be easier for me as a woman to
shun evil and embrace the good. It is sometimes incredibly hard for
me to not give into temptation.
If
we buy into the idea that women are naturally more spiritual than
men, I fear this may have a trickle-down effect on the way we raise
girls and boys.
If
girls are thought of as potentially more spiritual, then we may be
more comfortable discussing testimony and sharing feelings with them,
and asking them to express theirs.
If
boys are thought of as potentially less spiritual, then we may be
tempted to assume they are building enough testimony so long as they
are going through all the right motions. We can perhaps sense a bit
more reluctance in them to discuss feelings of a sacred or spiritual
nature, so we may not provide them with as many opportunities to
share them.
For
example, compare the experience we provide for our Young Women at
Girls’ Camp with the experience we provide for our Young Men at
Scout Camp.
I
remember my first year of Girls’ Camp. Ah, finally, I felt like
I was getting the kind of experiences boys had been getting in Cubs
for the past four years. Fire building, canoeing, campfire stories,
stargazing. It was awesome! At the end of the week there was a
testimony meeting around a campfire. It was special and I felt
uplifted.
The
next year when I attended, I was quite peeved to find that many of
the first aid, outdoor skill, and recreation activities had been
supplanted by “spiritual” activities. Commitment hike.
Phhht. Solitary scripture reading. Double Phhht. Evening with the
bishop. Grump-grump-grumpity-grump.
I
was not thrilled.
However,
as I continued to attend over the next few years, I grew to
appreciate those experiences for their testimony building value. I
saw them as they were — opportunities to search my feelings
deeply and commit to a Christian life in the Church.
Now,
I am not trying to knock Scout camp here. My experience with it is
admittedly limited; I have attended one of the Family Camps the BSA
puts on, and it was tons of fun. I love all the skills and activities
the Scouts get to participate in, as well as the leadership
opportunities and the camaraderie of hangin’ with the boys,
away from parents and girls. These are important, positive things.
But
it seems to me that the experiences they aren’t given at
camp is somewhat telling.
Where
are the opportunities for our Young Men to have quiet time in the
woods alone with only their scriptures for an hour? When is their
campfire testimony meeting? What about their evening with the bishop
when they can ask him any question they want anonymously without
their parents around?
It
makes me wonder: are we giving them adequate opportunity and
encouragement to develop their own relationship with the Savior?
Are
we providing an environment where our boys feel safe to express their
tender feelings about God and His gospel?
My
dad is a crier. I love it about him. He cries at the drop of the
spiritual hat. Feeling the whisperings of the Holy Spirit is
hardwired to his tear ducts.
This
is why, when in high school I was dating my now-husband, and I caught
him teary-eyed a time or two at Seminary, I knew he was the guy for
me.
I
was rather disappointed to discover that a mission had dried up his
tear ducts.
Yes,
of course, I was glad he served an honorable mission. But, being
around all these other men who more successfully held their emotions
in check while discussing spiritual things seemed to have “toughened”
him up a bit and he no longer wore his emotions on his sleeve.
Over
time, however, I am glad to report that fatherhood has brought them
back to some extent.
I
think it is sad that he felt comfortable expressing his spirituality
in an open way with his high school girlfriend, but not with his
mission companions. I wonder how common an experience this is, and
whether we are doing enough to nurture a willingness in our young men
to be this in-touch with their spiritual feelings.
At
the end of the day, the “women are more spiritual” myth
seems to feed the “boys are broken girls” philosophy.
Boys are capable of spirituality that is just as deep and feelings
that are just as powerful as any girl has. They may express it
somewhat differently, but we as an LDS culture can make those
expressions more frequent if we make it safe to have them.
Emily
Jorgensen received her bachelor's degree in piano performance from
Brigham Young University. She earned her master's degree in
elementary music education, also at BYU. She holds a Kodaly
certificate in choral education, as well as permanent certification
in piano from Music Teacher’s National Association.
She
has taught piano, solfege, and children’s music classes for 17
years in her own studio. She has also taught group piano classes at
BYU.
She
is an active adjudicator throughout the Wasatch Front and has served
in local, regional, and state positions Utah Music Teachers'
Association, as well as the Inspirations arts contest chair at
Freedom Academy.
She
gets a lot of her inspiration for her column by parenting her own
rambunctious four children, aged from “in diapers” to
“into Harry Potter.” She is still married to her high
school sweetheart and serves in her ward’s Primary.