Jean
Valjean, a good and honest man, stole a loaf of bread to feed a
starving nephew. He then spent 19 brutal years as Prisoner 24601 in
post-revolutionary French prisons, paying for his crime. Following
his parole, Valjean has little hope of surviving, short of turning to
a life of crime. The compassion of a priest gives him a new lease on
life, and he defies the terms of his parole and starts a new
existence, becoming a mayor and a successful, respected businessman.
Years
later, a ruthless and merciless inspector of police, Javert, finally
catches up with Valjean and is determined to return him to prison for
violating his parole. Valjean, however, has promised a destitute
factory worker, Fantine, that he will care for her young daughter,
Cosette, who has been in the questionable guardianship of some
innkeepers of ill-repute, the Thénardiers. So Valjean rescues
Cosette and flees from Javert, living quietly in seclusion for many
years, raising his adopted daughter.
Lives
and circumstances collide during the June Rebellion of 1832, and
Valjean again comes face-to-face with his nemesis, Javert. But he
also must come to terms with the fact that his daughter is no longer
a little girl and, in fact, Cosette has fallen in love with Marius, a
student leader in the rebellion. Further complicating this
relationship is the fact that Eponine, the daughter of the
Thénardiers, is also in love with Marius. An ill-fated
barricade in the streets of Paris brings all of them together and
sets the stage for resolution and absolution.
Les
Misérables
is hardly the first adaptation for stage or screen of Victor Hugo’s
masterpiece, but this masterful imagining is unique in many respects.
It is important to understand first that this is a musical production
in the truest sense of the word; there are scarcely 20 lines of
spoken dialogue in the entire 157 minutes of film.
One
of the advantages I believe musical theater has over film musicals is
the ability to infuse spontaneous, raw emotion in the performance of
musical numbers. Live performances are always new, and an actor can
add slight nuance and variation from performance to performance,
finding subtle ways to reveal the truth of the moment. They are not
limited to a rigid recitation and are free to experiment with
syncopations sympathetic to their emotions. They are, however,
physically locked to a stage, so the audience must choose for
themselves where to direct their attention and what to focus on.
A
film director, on the other hand, has the power to control the
viewer’s gaze and to introduce a multitude of visual references
to enhance and underscore the performance. However, because film is
made up of thousands of tiny clips stitched together to tell a
seamless story, the individual bits and pieces must have some
commonalities that allow them to cut together. Dialogue is relatively
simple to splice together, as long as the lines are the same (or at
least very similar) from different takes of the same scene. Spoken
lines are one thing, but sung lines are another entirely, and two
performances of someone singing are virtually impossible to mesh
together for a host of different reasons. So what we are typically
left with in movie musicals is a pre-recorded musical track that
actors then sing-along to, basically acting with their bodies while
lip-syncing with their mouths. It works well enough, obviously,
because we’ve been enjoying musicals for 80 years or so that
were filmed in this fashion.
What
director Tom Hooper (who also directed the brilliant The
King’s Speech
in 2010) set out to do -- and
did
-- with Les
Misérables
was to somehow amalgamate the best of both stage and cinema. What if
you could bring all the power and artistry of movie cameras and
beautiful sets and scenery and combine them with live, unrecorded
musical performances? That would, in theory, allow actors to do what
they do best, to squeeze their heart and soul out of every part of
their performance, unencumbered by choices made weeks or months
before in a dark recording studio, before they were endowed with
costumes and makeup and props, before they had been introduced to
their fellow actors, before they became intimately familiar with the
characters they would bring to life, and before the story they were
telling had woven itself into the very fiber of their beings.
What
we experience, then, is as powerful visually as it is musically,
sight and sound serving as symbiotic partners in a stunning sensory
presentation. Hugh Jackman does the yeoman work of stringing all the
story’s parts together as Jean Valjean. His singing and his
acting are strong -- as they are for the vast majority of the cast --
and he easily earns our sympathy as we watch him struggle against
seemingly insurmountable odds. Anne Hathaway as Fantine is
heart-breakingly believable, and the power of her performance of
I Dreamed A Dream
is pure and poignant.
Helena
Bonham Carter and Sacha Baron Cohen play the delightfully wicked
Thénardiers. And while Helena Bonham Carter is wonderfully
versatile in nearly everything she does, I typically have little use
for Cohen. With the exception of his work in Hugo
and the Madagascar
films, most of what he brings to the screen is at best tripe, crude
and intentionally offensive with no real redeeming value. His work
here, however, is spot-on. Their rendition of Master
of the House
at once paints an appropriately sordid picture of the squalid state
of society whilst being highly amusing and entertaining, and
providing much-needed comic relief to an otherwise dark and heavy
story.
Aaron
Tveit is appropriately charismatic as the rebel leader Enjolras, and
Samantha Barks will rip your heart out as Éponine. Amanda
Seyfried as the grown-up Cosette will melt even the hardest heart,
and young Daniel Huttlestone as Gavroche almost steals the movie on
more than one occasion. Eddie Redmayne as Marius delivers a
show-stopping rendition of Empty
Chairs at Empty Tables
that will have you digging in your pockets for tissues. And there are
countless other actors whose names I do not know but whose
performances are nonetheless amazing. In fact, the group number of Do
You Hear the People Sing?
will make you want to stand up in the theater and start waving a flag
or something, that is if you can stop crying.
So
this brilliant movie is filled with incredibly talented songbirds,
whose individual and collective voices weave a musical tapestry that
has scarcely been assembled previously on the big screen. Which is
what ironically makes Russell Crowe’s name particularly
appropriate as he squawks his way through song after song as Javert
with merely adequate results. In certain circles, Crowe might be
considered a reasonable singer, but certainly not when he is
surrounded by a legion of top-shelf talent. But this is a minor
squabble; I like Russell Crowe, but I wish he had gone a little Rex
Harrison and talk-sung his way through these numbers. Harrison could
hardly sing a note, yet is remembered fondly and perhaps best for his
roles in some rather meaty musicals!
Les
Mis
is long, but doesn’t feel like it. Its message is heavy and
thought-provoking and,
at times, depressing. But it is also a powerful story of
perseverance, and there is a strong undercurrent of hope that flows
throughout. It is a remarkably timeless reminder that despite the
bleak backdrop of life in a fallen and failing world, we need not
surrender to despair and depravity. Simple acts of kindness and
charity can change lives and, indeed, the world. And when we rise
above our natural tendencies, then redemption and atonement are
within the grasp of all of us, and the soul that we save may well be
our own.
Andy Lindsay can frequently be overheard engaged in conversations that consist entirely of repeating lines of dialogue from movies, a genetic disorder he has passed on to his four children and one which his wife tolerates but rarely understands. When Andy's not watching a movie he's probably talking about a movie or thinking about a movie.
Or, because his family likes to eat on a somewhat regular basis, he just might be working on producing a TV commercial or a documentary or a corporate video or a short film. His production company is Barking Shark Creative, and you can check out his work here www.barkingshark.com.
Andy grew up in Frederick, Maryland, but migrated south to North Carolina where he met his wife, Deborah, who wasn't his wife then but later agreed to take the job. Their children were all born and raised in Greensboro, but are in various stages of growing up and running away.
Andy (or Anziano Lindsay, as he was known then) served a full-time mission for the Church in Italy, and today he teaches Sunday School, works with the Scouts, and is the Stake Video Historian.