"We seldom get into trouble when we speak softly. It is only when we raise our voices that the sparks fly and tiny molehills become great mountains of contention."
We
went to see “The Monuments Men” last week. I know that
the movie has generally come and gone, but it was playing at the
second-run bargain theater just over the county line, so we went.
I
know that some critics and patrons felt disappointed in it, and their
assessments have merit. It could have been stronger in character
development and a little tighter in execution, moving the plot along.
But this is not a movie review.
I
found myself responding to it in a quieter space, feeling the import
of what they were doing. I have had a personal link to one Alsatian
Jew’s story, a gifted artist and collector who had to leave
everything behind and flee for his life, whose artworks were never
seen again, so the tale makes that connection with me.*
The
story takes place as the war is in its final days; the horrors of the
camps had been found and the stories we are so familiar with were
known to the men we follow in this rescue campaign. That enables the
exposition to follow its own line, acknowledging but not dwelling on
those horrors. This story is to tell of other, less celebrated
heroics.
It
is their purpose itself that is the center of the story, the focus of
the film. The plea for action is impassioned, as the disinclined
military leadership asks the question — “Is art, any art,
really worth risking men’s lives?” In the years to come,
will anyone care?
With
the perspective of our later time, I think we agree with their
answer, that yes, it can be, and yes, they will. How we yearn for
those treasures in antiquity that are lost forever; in this case we
are familiar with the riches that were at risk, and they speak to us.
But
as I watched and listened to the actions of the Nazis, and the race
to retrieve as much as possible from their thefts, I pondered. The
Nazis didn’t just steal great and famous artworks; they were
determined to destroy them if they couldn’t get away with them.
Why
was that so important to them? I recognized that on one level it was
the arrogance of, “If I can’t have it, no one can have
it.” It was spite, it was cruelty, it was domination. And
yet, that wasn’t all it was.
Why
would Satan make the extra push to inspire them (I hate to even use
that term) to gather up everything they could find and burn it? To
rush to do so before they would flee, when flight was imperative?
Why
did the art matter so much to
him?
Because make no mistake, this was a work of evil, and not just ego
and a mindset of power and abuse. Make no mistake, Satan was behind
all the
works of Nazi annihilation in all their guises.
What
does art do for us? What did such works as the altarpieces
of Ghent mean, which was painted in the 1400’s and has been revered for
centuries, which they were determined to destroy?
Or
the sculpture of the Madonna
and child at Bruges, the only Michelangelo marble to leave Italy in his
lifetime. It cost a good man his life.
I
recognized with the quiet touch of the Holy Ghost that these works of
power and beauty, in their many different forms, serve to draw the
heart to God for those who see and feel their meaning. They speak to
the majesty, the mercy, and the love of God for us, and they speak to
our transcendent possibilities and hopes.
Great
art, and great beauty wherever it is found, can open us to the
presence of God. No wonder Satan wanted it all destroyed. I watched
the rest of the story, as it unfolded, from that perspective.
Our
13th Article of Faith reads, “We believe in being
honest, true, chaste benevolent, virtuous, and in doing good to all
men. Indeed, we may say that we follow the admonition of Paul —
We believe all things, we hope all things, we have endured many
things, and hope to be able to endure all things. If there is
anything virtuous, lovely, or of good report or praiseworthy, we seek
after these things.”
What
was Paul’s admonition? It’s found here,
in I Corinthians 13, regarding charity, that charity “rejoiceth
not in
iniquity,
but
rejoiceth
in the truth;
beareth
all things,
believeth
all things,
hopeth all
things,
endureth
all things.”
Charity endures forever and never fails.
Joseph
Smith’s article of faith takes that admonition and adds a
declaration that we seek after all things that are virtuous, lovely,
or of good report or praiseworthy because those are the things that
will draw us nearer to God, who leads us to charity, or perfect love.
Those
are the things that open our hearts and carry us through our trials.
Both cleaving to truth and hope and filling our experience with what
uplifts or reminds us are part of the spiritual equation of pressing
forward with steadfast faith in Christ.
Much
of what was taken by the Nazis was religious art. Much of it was
not, but those things that draw our hearts towards a yearning for a
better world, or for our better natures, still open us spiritually
even without an overtly religious subject.
Beauty
in our lives matters. The connection of generations of human
outpouring does help define us through our art and culture. Even
those works that depict the pains of the human condition can speak to
us of our commonalities as mortal beings, giving empathy, or give us
quiet reflection on the things we may suffered or have overcome.
Great
works of art speak to the soul. It goes deeper than the surface of
our ordinary daily experience. Roosevelt termed them “symbols
of the human spirit, and of the world the freedom of the human spirit
made.”
Satan
doesn’t want our souls open, he absolutely does not. He
doesn’t want us to contemplate wonder, awe, or freedom. His
goal is always, always, to diminish us. We can see a great many
things around us in our day that are celebrated but not
virtuous or lovely — and they will ultimately not endure.
It’s
not often that you can go to a movie and find spiritual experience
and meaning, but last week, in this story, I did.
Marian J. Stoddard was born in Washington, D.C., and grew up in its Maryland suburbs. Her
father grew up in Carson City, Nevada, and her mother in Salt Lake City, so she was always
partly a Westerner at heart, and she ended up raising her family in Washington State. Her family
took road trips all over the United States and Canada, so there were lots of adventures.
The adventures of music, literature, and art were also valued and pursued. Playing tourist always
included the local museums as well as historical sites and places of natural beauty. Discussions
at home, around the dinner table or working in the kitchen, could cover politics, philosophy, or
poetry, with the perspective of the gospel underlying all. Words and ideas, and testimony and
service, were the family currency.
Marian graduated from Winston Churchill High School in Potomac, Maryland, and attended the
University of Utah as the recipient of the Ralph Hardy Memorial Scholarship, where she was
graduated with honors, receiving a B.A. in English. She also met the love of her life, a law
student, three weeks after her arrival; she jokes that she had to marry him because her mother
always wanted a tenor in the family. (She sings second soprano.) They were married two years
later and have six children and six grandchildren (so far). She treasures her family, her friends,
and her opportunities to serve.
Visit Marian at her blog, greaterthansparrows. You can contact her at
bloggermarian@gmail.com.
Marian and her husband live in Tacoma, Washington. Together they teach those who are
preparing to go to the temple for the first time, and she also teaches a Stake Relief Society
Institute class.