Fetching the Fetchiest Art Story Ever Told, Part 2
by Lawrence Jeppson
Last
week we left the Marques de Valfierno and Yves Chaudron in
Mexico City awash in fake Murillo paintings. Chaudron
was the faker, his partner the seller.
Chaudron
became bored with painting so many replicas of the same painting. To
keep up with Valfierno’s galloping success, he began hiring
Mexican painters to do his work.
It
was not a good move. The Mexicans were too talkative to fit into such
a well-oiled confidence scam. As work leaked out, grifters and crooks
tried to muscle in. That crumbled the cookie. Valfierno and Chaudron
took off for Paris, loaded with their loot from Buenos Aires and
Mexico City.
In
France every year, scores of questionable works by Jean Baptiste
Camille Corot, Jean François Millet, Titian, and others were
sold, overcrowding the fakery market. Valfierno, swollen with pride,
yearned to do something more prestigious, lucrative, and daring.
He
set about engineering the supreme coup in art forgery.
From
the crowd of confidence men Valfierno knew, he recruited three: a
monocled Englishman of impressive nonchalance, a Frenchman who had
all the right connections, and an American who knew a sizable
percentage of those listed in the Social Register.
The
ring set up headquarters in a villa not far from the Place de
l’Etoile. Their target area included a score of the most
expensive hotels in Paris. They entertained lavishly —
apéritifs, fine French cuisine and wines, champagne, Napoléon
brandy is large snifters, rich Havana cigars. As hosts, the four men
were carefully careless talkers, given to intimations, nonchalant
innuendos, blatant boastings.
They
could do anything for a friend. The friend had only to ask. Did he
need a string pulled in the French bureaucracy? Did he want to meet
the glittering star of the Folies Bergère?
The
delivery of these precious services quickly certified the
conspirators’ skill and reliability. Valfierno’s crew
began selling little things from the Louvre. Nothing was actually
ever stolen, although the buyers thought otherwise.
A
buyer who expressed interest in a particular painting and was willing
to pay an appropriate price soon found it delivered with a sheaf of
Louvre documents to his doorstep, usually outside of France.
The
dossier always included at least one marked “secret,”
which stated that the painting was missing but, to suppress public
scandal, had been replaced by a replica.
For
three years the ring sold fine things from the Louvre.
Then
one night when the four men and a greedy collector were very far
along the champagne trail, one of the ring boasted that they might
steal the Mona Lisa for their guest.
“Why
not?” the American suggested.
Valfierno
and the others expected a rebuff from their guest. They were stunned
by his outrageous response to their jest.
“Why
not?” the collector repeated. “It has never been done,
but that is no reason it could not be done, and knowing Paris as you
do, you should be able to manage it.”
Chaudron
began making more frequent trips to the Louvre to study a single
painting, Mona Lisa.
Leonardo da Vinci, the genuine Mona Lisa, aka La Giaconda, Louvre.
Valfierno’s
ring had several ambiguities working for them. There had long been a
question about the authenticity of the Louvre painting — or at
least its uniqueness. Some thought da Vinci had painted it at least
twice. Recently this idea has made headlines.
Whatever
the battle might be among experts, the ring could not sell any
Chaudron copy as along as the Mona Lisa hung in the Louvre.
According
to a confession made by Valfierno to Karl Decker in a Casablanca
saloon in 1914 and finally published in The Saturday Evening Post
in 1932, after Valfierno and Chaudron were dead, Valfierno hired an
Italian, Vincenzo Perugia, to steal the painting. An employee of the
Louvre, Perugia had worked for Valfierno before, but he knew nothing
of the forgeries.
Meanwhile,
Valfierno and his cronies were quietly striking bargains for the
eventual delivery in America of the one-and-only real Mona Lisa.
Mondays
are cleaning days in the museum, when it is closed to the public.
Except on crowded weekends and holidays, in the Louvre and Prado and
other famed museums, copyists are allowed to set up easels so they
can study and try to replicate Old Masters.
They
are not allowed to make their copies in the same size as the
originals. Storage closets are provided so that copyists don’t
have to trundle their easels, camp stools, canvases, and paints in
and out of the museum for every session.
Like
other copyists, Chaudron set himself up every day in front of the
Mona Lisa and painted her. At this point he was not painting a
replica to sell but was seeking the best way to successfully
counterfeit the original.
The
original was painted on a wood panel, and Chaudron found panels of
appropriate age and size. Slowly he began making a faithful replica.
After he finished it, he painted another, and then another.
When
the first copy was completed, it was quietly shipped to the United
States and made it through Customs declared as a copy. Others
followed. Their presence was kept secret.
By
the time Chaudron had finished six new Mona Lisas, the ring
decided that it could not delay much longer in delivering the
original. Max Friedlander, one of the most respected art experts of
the day, once observed, “Forgeries must be served hot as they
come from the oven.”
About
4:00 P.M, Sunday, 20 August 1911, Perugia and two other men entered
the crowded museum, mingled with the visitors, and when the coast was
clear, hid themselves in the copyists’ closets, where they
remained long after the museum was cleared and closed for the day.
Early
Monday morning when the maintenance crews began work, Perugia and his
helpers slipped into Louvre workmen’s smuggled garb and
pretended to be busy with assigned tasks. Unfortunately, Picquet, the
head workman, was caught up in some repairs in the Grand Gallery,
adjacent to the Salon Carré, the fabled painting’s home
and where Napoleon had married Josephine.
He
was in and out constantly, and Perugia could do nothing until Picquet
went off to another part of the museum.
While
working in the museum, Perugia had helped cobble the shadow box and
frame that displayed the painting. He knew exactly how much it
weighed and how it was attached to the wall.
At
7:20 the thieves unhooked their prize and began carrying it off.
Three men carrying a painting on a working day was not something
unusual. Once they entered a stairway used only by staff, they paused
to remove the wood panel and abandoned the framing ensemble.
Then
disaster struck. Valfierno had used a wax impression to make a key
for a stairway door they had to go through. Perugia had never tested
it. It did not work. Furious, Perugia yanked a screwdriver from his
pocket and set about stripping the lock itself. He had removed the
bronze knob and was twisting out the next screw when his accomplice
outside the Salle de Sèpt Metres whistled. Someone was coming.
Perugia
dropped the knob into his pocket and hid the painting under his
workman’s cover. The intruder happened to be the museum
plumber. Perugia lost no time complaining that someone had swiped the
doorknob and he couldn’t open the door. The plumber obligingly
took out his key and unlocked the door and went on his way.
The
men went the rest of the way down the stairs and found a wide open
door to the street. The guard had gone off to get a bucket of water
to wash the vestibule. A car was waiting. Within 15 minutes painting
and thief were in the ring’s headquarters, after completing the
art heist of the century.
The
theft of Mona Lisa was not discovered until the next day,
Tuesday. At 9:00 A.M. a painter named Louis Beroud arrived. He was
painting a picture of the Salon Carré itself and complained
about the absence of the da Vinci. Brigadier Poupardin, the head of
the Louvre guards, assured him that the painting must have been
removed for photographing. Beroud asked again when Poupardin passed
through at noon.
When
Poupardin checked with the photography studio, he learned the
painting was not there. An alarm was passed upwards through the chain
of bureaucratic channels until it reached the acting head of the
museum. The Louvre immediately went into lockdown. Every nook and
cranny was searched.
Of
course, nothing was found but the abandoned detritus.
Sensational
stories filled the press, as a chain of official inquiries escalated
in the museum and the French government. Heads rolled.
The
scandal was great news for Valfierno and his gang. They quickly sold
“the real Mona Lisa” to their larcenous buyers,
who would never be able to let anyone else ever see their prize.
Many
years later the story floated in Paris that a certain well-known
American collector, whom I will not identify, was offered “the
stolen Mona Lisa” by two different intermediaries. Not
being able to tell which of the two was the genuine stolen painting
and which was the fake, and unable to consult an expert, he purchased
them both.
Lawrence Jeppson is an art consultant, organizer and curator of art exhibitions, writer, editor
and publisher, lecturer, art historian, and appraiser. He is America's leading authority on
modern, handwoven French tapestries. He is expert on the works of William Henry Clapp, Nat
Leeb, Tsing-fang Chen, and several French artists.
He is founding president of the non-profit Mathieu Matégot Foundation for Contemporary
Tapestry, whose purview encompasses all 20th-century tapestry, an interest that traces back to
1948. For many years he represented the Association des Peintres-Cartonniers de Tapisserie and
Arelis in America.
Through the Smithsonian Institution Traveling Exhibition Service, the American Federation of
Arts, the Museum of Modern Art, and his own Art Circuit Services he has been a contributor to
or organizer of more than 200 art exhibitions in the United States, Canada, Japan, and Taiwan.
He owns AcroEditions, which publishes and/or distributes multiple-original art. He was co-founder and artistic director of Collectors' Investment Fund.
He is the director of the Spring Arts Foundation; Utah Cultural Arts Foundation, and the Fine
Arts Legacy Foundation
Lawrence is an early-in-the-month home teacher, whose beat is by elevator. In addition, he has spent the past six years hosting and promoting reunions of the missionaries who served in the French Mission (France, Belgium, and Switzerland) during the decade after WWII.