The
information technology world changes so rapidly that a person
employed in it can discover his expertise outmoded in a fortnight.
When
I was writing my book on art forgers it seemed that there was a
finite number of forgers — at least those who had been
discovered. A French sleuth, Guy Isnard, published Les Pirates de
la Peinture/The Pirates of Painting (1955), which pretty much
covered the scene.
He
followed this up in 1960, with two-volumes of Faux et Imitations
dans l’Art/ Fake and Imitations in Art cataloging all the
fakes and fakers going back centuries. In all three books he named
names.
Other
scholars and sleuths, mainly in Europe, published their books on
demons of fakery, and most of them noted the same individuals.
By
the late 1960s, other demons began cluttering the fakers scene, most
notably Elmyr de Hory and David Stein were plying center stage.
I
tried keeping up with the changing scene, but it has become almost
impossible. The world has become awash with individual fakers and
faking cabals. Art forgery has become big business, egged on by the
huge escalation of prices fetched by good stuff.
There
is a limited attempt to forge old masters. I see three reasons for
this. First, artists are unwilling to submit to the years of study,
practice, and refinement that students in Old Master generations
underwent. The skill has gone.
Second,
sophisticated, scientific cataloging and detection have made Old
Master fakery difficult to pull off.
Third,
the art world has broken into fragments, and lots of the pieces are
easy to fake.
When
I interviewed the New York City District Attorney regarding Stein, he
observed that Stein was successful because he imitated artists whose
work was childlike and easy to counterfeit. No great art connoisseur
himself, the D.A. was referring to Matisse, Picasso, and other
well-known figures.
In
future columns I’d like to examine some of these latter-day
counterfeiters. But for today’s Moments in Art, I’ll
delve into the follies of one old-timer and one from today’s
headlines.
The
oldie is Casper Caspersen, a skilled Norwegian cabinetmaker.
My
first information on Caspersen came from a long article in a
Norwegian newspaper. Although my great-grandmother came from the
southern tip of Norway, Norwegian disappeared from any family
knowledge after her children were gone.
I
took my newspaper to the Norwegian Embassy in Washington, D.C., where
a cultural attaché translated it for me and taught me how to
pronounce “Munch.”
Caspersen
did not have the moxie to design his own furniture. He copied what
others had created. He loved the art of countryman Edvard Munch, and
in privacy he painted Munch, Munch, Munch incessantly, much like the
French copyist who painted Mona Lisa 1000 times.
Munch
was not the easiest artist to copy. The greatest Scandinavian painter
of all time, he achieved his standing because his work expressed the
tumult and power of his unique emotions.
In
1944, Munch, 80, died, famous not only at home but in the world.
Caspersen was 40, and he worked in the Nasjonalgalleriet
(National Gallery), where he had many opportunities to study and
replicate the master’s work.
In
1950, a traveling Munch exhibition began touring American museums.
Soon afterwards bogus Munches began appearing in American
collections. Some of them had come through Oslo dealers. The City of
Oslo acquired the art which was left in the Munch estate.
Some
of these paintings were so badly damaged that the way to save them
was the very demanding conservation process of lifting the paint from
the original canvases and attaching it to new linen.
The
original frame and stretcher are removed from the painting, which is
laid face down on a hard, flat surface. Strips of paper 10" or
wider are pasted around the edge of the painting like a frame. The
strips are then wetted with water, which makes them shrink. This
stretches the canvas.
Layers
of plain newspaper or tissue are then glued to the face of the
picture. Any irregularities caused by overlapping sheets, wrinkles,
or minute glue bumps are sandpapered away.
The
whole assemblage is turned over and laid face-down on the flat
surface. The technician then wets the canvas, loosening the bond
between the canvas and the first layer of sizing. The sizing is
dissolved, and the canvas is carefully lifted away. What remains on
the table is the thin layer of paint, backside up.
After
the backside has been cleaned and treated with a relining glue, the
new canvas is applied. Then the newsprint and tissue on the front
side can be removed, and the relining process completed.
The
painting has been saved.
Caspersen
was asked to make new stretchers for the restored paintings. Since
the museum had no interest in keeping the old canvases, which had the
artist’s markings on them, Caspersen asked if he could have
them.
Caspersen
put the old canvases back on their old stretchers and then painted
new “Munches” on the surface. He told people he was
selling the paintings for “an old lady” who had acquired
them from the artist.
The
director of the Oslo Municipal Art Collection began expressing doubts
about Munch paintings in the Albright-Knox Gallery in Buffalo, the
Phillips Collection in Washington, and several private collections.
Suspicions
aroused, Oslo police began questioning Caspersen. Police and public
protested: no one was ever skilled enough to paint like the master.
His
ego aroused, Caspersen, in his cell, painted a new Summer
Landscape in just three hours.
It
was thought that the two dealers involved were not sufficiently
skilled to distinguish fake from genuine, and it was decided that
there was no evidence of wholesale forgery.
The
case against Caspersen was dropped, and he receded into his pre-Munch
oblivion.
According
to Lorena Munoz-Alonzo, reported in ArtNet, our second story began in
2003, when two Spanish brothers agreed to purchase a painting they
thought was by Goya for €270,000. After they laid out a deposit
of €20,000, the deal dissolved because of a lack of a
certificate of authenticity.
Much
later the deal was resurrected. An unidentified sheikh agreed to pay
the brothers ¤4 million for the Goya Portrait of don
Antonio Maria Esquivel. The brothers paid an unidentified
middleman ¤300,000.
Later,
police would find the fake Goya in one of the brothers’ homes.
Everything
came cascading apart when the brothers tried to deposit 1.7 million
Swiss francs in a Geneva bank. They were told that the banknotes were
mere photocopies.
The
middleman with his genuine ¤300,000 and the sheikh had
disappeared.
This
is the most ironic adventure in the encyclopedia of art forgery: a
fake “masterpiece” being purchased with fake money.
Fake Goya portrait seized by Spanish police. Photo via El Pais & Artnet
Lawrence Jeppson is an art consultant, organizer and curator of art exhibitions, writer, editor
and publisher, lecturer, art historian, and appraiser. He is America's leading authority on
modern, handwoven French tapestries. He is expert on the works of William Henry Clapp, Nat
Leeb, Tsing-fang Chen, and several French artists.
He is founding president of the non-profit Mathieu Matégot Foundation for Contemporary
Tapestry, whose purview encompasses all 20th-century tapestry, an interest that traces back to
1948. For many years he represented the Association des Peintres-Cartonniers de Tapisserie and
Arelis in America.
Through the Smithsonian Institution Traveling Exhibition Service, the American Federation of
Arts, the Museum of Modern Art, and his own Art Circuit Services he has been a contributor to
or organizer of more than 200 art exhibitions in the United States, Canada, Japan, and Taiwan.
He owns AcroEditions, which publishes and/or distributes multiple-original art. He was co-founder and artistic director of Collectors' Investment Fund.
He is the director of the Spring Arts Foundation; Utah Cultural Arts Foundation, and the Fine
Arts Legacy Foundation
Lawrence is an early-in-the-month home teacher, whose beat is by elevator. In addition, he has spent the past six years hosting and promoting reunions of the missionaries who served in the French Mission (France, Belgium, and Switzerland) during the decade after WWII.