"We seldom get into trouble when we speak softly. It is only when we raise our voices that the sparks fly and tiny molehills become great mountains of contention."
We all know that there are vivid sacrament meeting talks and dull ones, full
ones and empty ones.
Sometimes people think that the difference has something to do with the
manner of presentation. When a talk makes them feel inspired, they may
compliment the speaker for his or her "enthusiasm."
As often as not, it's not the enthusiasm of the speaker, but rather the truth in
the message that fills the listeners with a vigorous desire to act on what they
heard, or provides that glow of sudden understanding when a truth long
known is suddenly learned afresh.
I recently had a chance to look at a slim, useful book by Len Ellis, called Jump
Right In! Speaking with Fun & Ease. I'm not sure that "ease" will ever be a part
of public speaking for many people, but Ellis does offer many useful tips for
those who would like to do a better, more effective job of speaking.
Perhaps most importantly, he helps timid speakers find the courage to speak at
all. I recommend the book http://jumprightinnow.com.
When it comes to speaking in sacrament meeting, I've learned over my sixty-one years that it matters little to me whether someone's talk is read or spoken,
whether the speaker makes eye contact or stares down at the paper.
If you have nothing to say, then it certainly helps to be very entertaining about
saying nothing. You may be complimented on the talk because of your manner
of delivery. Yet your audience will still be hungry at the end.
In my view, here is the single most important thing that determines whether
people come out of that sacrament meeting feeling filled or depleted, inspired or
weary:
True stories from the speaker's own life. Either you have them or you don't.
When you're assigned to give a sermon in sacrament meeting, it wasn't a
General Authority who was called on to speak, nor was it an ancient prophet.
It was you.
I remember buying the first book by an Apostle whom I much admired as a
thinker and speaker. But to my disappointment, the book was empty.
No, no, there were words printed on every page. They were almost entirely
quotations from scriptures and from other General Authorities. But I had
already read the originals. There was nothing of the man himself.
He might have thought he was following the admonition and example of Nephi:
"And I did read many things unto them which were written in the books
of Moses; but that I might more fully persuade them to believe in the
Lord their Redeemer I did read unto them that which was written by the
prophet Isaiah; for I did liken all scriptures unto us, that it might be for
our profit and learning" (1 Ne 19:23).
What is the lesson we really learn from the writings of Nephi? I know what he
said -- but what did he do as he wrote his books?
Late in his writings, we get chapter after chapter of quotations from Isaiah.
Tell the truth now -- your eyes glaze over and you're tempted to skip to where
the quotations stop and Nephi starts talking again.
Yet early on, when Nephi tells us stories from his own life, his teaching is vivid,
powerful, unforgettable. Obtaining the plates; the Tree of Life; the broken bow;
building the ship; the storm at sea. The stories stick in our memory.
Without realizing it, Nephi demonstrated what is and is not effective in
teaching. He is most powerful when he speaks from his own life.
Now, some people imagine that because they are not mighty prophets, because
angels have not stopped the wicked from beating them, because their prayers
have not stilled a storm at sea, they have nothing to offer.
So they read from a General Authority's talk, or quote scripture after scripture;
they think that in this way, they can be sure to speak with authority.
But you speak with most "authority" when you are the author of your words.
To do that, however, you have to look at your life, not for the miracles in it, but
for the plain lessons that can be learned.
Let me give you an example from one of the best sacrament meeting talks I've
ever heard. The speaker was Mike Lewis, a geography professor who delights
in taking his students out into the wilderness to see the lay of the land for
themselves.
When he was bishop of our ward, he took some of our Young Men with him,
including my older son, on a trip to Big Bend National Park in Texas. One day
he led them on a hike to a landmark called the Mule Ears. They parked at a
dry wash and followed a steep but well-marked trail to a low saddle in a ridge.
In his words:
Leaving the marked trail at the saddle we picked our way cross-country along
the rocky ridge for above a mile to the Mule Ears. We made it there with no
trouble and spent an hour or two scrambling on the boulders at the base of the
dikes, wondering what it might be like to climb them with climbing gear, or
what it was like to fly an airplane between them. About noon we ate the
lunches we had packed and had a drink of water before heading back.
When we reached the saddle again, we stopped to rest. It was getting hot and I
wondered if there might be a better way to the trailhead than following the trail
we came in on. I fancy myself as being pretty good at reading a map and
interpreting the lay of the land. (After all, I am an Eagle Scout and have three
degrees in geography).
My USGS topographic map of the area suggested a much shorter way back that
would help us avoid the heat. I could see that by following a compass heading
to the southeast we would drop off through some rough badlands for just a
short distance, but beyond that was a wide gently sloping pediment that led to
the sandy arroyo where the car was parked.
I told the boys to wait at the saddle while I went to scout my short cut. I
walked out to the upper edge of the badlands and stopped and looked out
across the wide desert pediment.
What I saw was worse than a mist of darkness. Most people know that
dangerous creatures live in the Chihuahuan desert: at least three kinds of
rattlesnakes, several types of scorpions, and some very big spiders, for
example.
But the truth is such things are relatively scarce in the day time and easy to
avoid by wearing thick boots and long pants and not sticking your fingers or
toes into dark places without a good look first.
The thing that is most likely to harm you in the desert is the vegetation. In Big
Bend the vegetation all has Spanish names, but the friendly Texans have
translated the names into English to forewarn Americans who refuse to learn
Spanish.
From where I stood on top of the badlands, I could see a wide thicket of drab
green brush at the bottom of the slope. It was a solid cover of "cat claw" acacia
that we would most likely have to crawl through.
Beyond that was a maze of dense mats of a spikey succulent called lechuguilla,
or "the dagger" in English.
At first it looked like we might be able to wind our way between the mats of
daggers, but skulking in those narrow openings were squat round cacti with
rigid spikes in a ring around their centers. At the center of the ring is a
thicker, longer spike.
These are the "horse crippler" cacti, which can puncture not only horses'
hooves, but thick boot leather.
If that wasn't enough, among the daggers and the horse cripplers were clusters
of long stemmed nearly leafless shrubs, with ribs all around the woody stems
that were lined with thorns long enough for birds to perch on. These are the
"coach whips," or ocotillo in Spanish.
Finally, there was a small, uncommon, yet deadly plant that is among the most
feared of all. Its leaves have razor-sharp edges and their tips form a long
stinging barb. When broken, the leaves ooze a poisonous, sticky red liquid.
The English name for this? "Mother-in-law's tongue."
Besides the hazards posed by the vegetation, our water supply was another
issue to consider. Desert pediments are eroded into bedrock and are
notoriously lacking in water sources. I pulled out my water bottle and found it
about three-quarters empty.
For 360 degrees around I had an open view, and I looked for any signs of water
in the dancing heat waves. Far off in the distance was a single tall green
cottonwood tree. It was the only tall green tree anywhere in sight, and it was
tucked up in a ravine coming down the bare mountain slope we had walked in
on that morning.
I checked my map again and noticed something I hadn't seen before. It was a
small blue circle with a short blue tail, the universal map symbol for a spring.
What's more, the spring was on a short side trail that joined the trail we had
hiked in on earlier.
In the cool of the morning, with plenty of water to carry, I wasn't thirsty and
hadn't looked up that ravine or seen that tree. Now it was hot and my water
was running low. I began to appreciate the wisdom of whoever laid out that
trail, and why it followed a longer, circuitous route along the mountain slope.
I went back to the saddle where the boys were waiting on the trail, and said
something like, "I'm not so smart after all, we need to stay on this trail and
make for that big green tree."
We did that and found a small muddy seep of water. It didn't really produce
enough water to filter for a drink, but it was enough to wet down a bandana.
It's hard to describe how good a wet bandana feels on a sunburned face as
you're lying down in a small patch of wiry green grass in the shade of a green
tree, while surrounded by a great expanse of hot, dry desert.
Like the numberless concourses of people Lehi saw along the straight and
narrow path we sometimes walk along the well-marked path when times are
good without paying much attention to our surroundings, just going with the
flow, maybe staring at our feet and not really noticing important landmarks,
like springs and green trees in a desert.
At times we may think ourselves smarter or wiser than those were marked the
path and are leading us to our goal. We think we see better ways across the
deserts of the world. We may attempt to make the scriptures conform to our
way of thinking, or rely on charismatic pundits to justify changing our
direction of travel.
Family and church leaders plead with us to check our water supply and read
the map again, to reach out for the iron rod and get back on the right trail.
Why is that so important? Because eternal life depends on it.
His delivery was good -- he's an excellent teacher and he's at ease talking to
large groups of people. But it wasn't the delivery that captivated us. It was the
story.
It was a true story. It was of an adventure none of us would have. Yet he
found meaning in it that applied to every one of us. He brought the scriptures
into our lives.
In the rest of the talk, he quoted scriptures from the vision of the Tree of Life in
the first book of Nephi. Because of the story he had just told, we heard those
scriptures differently, with fresh ears.
He told other stories. One was from a stake youth "handcart trek." Another
was from the life of Elder Bruce R. McConkie. These stories were also quite
effective.
The personal story from Big Bend was not the whole talk. But it was the heart
of it.
There are countless sermons in your life, if you reflect on your experiences and
find the lessons there. As in Mike Lewis's story, you may not be the hero of the
story; you may not come off looking terribly wise. (Though I think anyone who
scouts out a shortcut first, and thinks long and hard before taking my son
down that path, is a hero, and very wise indeed!)
You have those stories in your life. You have dozens of them. Hundreds of
them.
So when you prepare your sacrament meeting talks, by all means consult the
scriptures and read from many sources.
But also search your own memory. The Spirit will help you recognize the
sermons in your life.
We come to sacrament meeting on that day to hear you speak, from your life,
which will help us find the gospel lessons in our own.
NOTE: To read the full text of Michael E. Lewis's talk, download this .pdf.
Orson Scott Card is the author of the novels Ender's Game, Ender's
Shadow, and Speaker for the Dead, which are widely read by adults and
younger readers, and are increasingly used in schools.
Besides these and other science fiction novels, Card writes contemporary
fantasy (Magic Street,Enchantment,Lost Boys), biblical novels (Stone Tables,Rachel and Leah), the American frontier fantasy series The Tales of Alvin Maker
(beginning with Seventh Son), poetry (An Open Book), and many plays and
scripts.
Card was born in Washington and grew up in California, Arizona, and
Utah. He served a mission for the LDS Church in Brazil in the early 1970s.
Besides his writing, he teaches occasional classes and workshops and directs
plays. He also teaches writing and literature at Southern Virginia University.
Card currently lives in Greensboro, North Carolina, with his wife,
Kristine Allen Card, and their youngest child, Zina Margaret.