Many people have a misconception about management. We get the idea that
it's about assignments and accounting. Managers give training and set goals;
workers do their work and fill out reports. You can look at the paperwork and
know just how everyone's doing.
The trouble is that, as every good manager knows, you can look at the reports
and know absolutely nothing at all. Yes, productivity is down, but why?
Turnover is high, but why? If anybody knew the answer well enough to put it
into a report, then the problems probably wouldn't exist in the first place.
This applies as much to church callings as any other managerial
responsibilities. In fact, I daresay that most of our callings deal with one
aspect of management or another.
Bishoprics and presidencies have managerial assignments, of course, but so
does every teacher in every organization. Because it's not just about preparing
a lesson and "giving" it -- you have to manage the class.
While management has a reporting aspect, in the gospel as well as in the
business world, the most important aspects of management can't be charted or
plotted or numbered or crunched.
Latter-day Saints know that true management, at church and everywhere else,
is taught in Section 121 of the Doctrine & Covenants, where we're told how
authority should and should not be exercised.
But sometimes we need help from someone who approaches the problem from
another angle. I remember that on my mission, Stephen R. Covey's book
Spiritual Roots of Human Relations illuminated the principles of leadership in
ways that I could not have gleaned from the scriptures on my own.
Even Covey's excellent book leaned toward methodology -- scheduling time for
this, planning for that, setting goals. But much of the time, the problems we're
dealing with in our church callings are not a matter of making lists or
appointments.
Too often we think of "managing" as scheduling time or accomplishing tasks,
but, at church especially, it's always about people more than anything else.
And people don't like to be managed.
Oh, what, that comes as a surprise to you? Every elders quorum president
who has tried to set home teaching goals knows the futility of the goal-and-report method of getting people to do things.
Most of the time, numerical goals at church are pure fantasy. Too much
depends on what other people want and decide. If you start doing something
better, then it's true the numbers might come up. But thinking of how to
"bring the numbers up" will not lead you to real improvement.
If the class you teach is failing, you can't improve it by setting attendance goals
for the class members! "How many of you can commit to one hundred percent
attendance this month!" You would merely look needy and desperate; nothing
would improve.
And yet we use that method over and over in other areas, with the same result
-- the people we're supposedly managing seem to agree, but in fact what we get
is somewhere between sullen compliance and smiling defiance.
I have a book for you. I read it in two hours one night -- and that included
stopping and thinking about the ideas in it. The book is The Three Signs of a
Miserable Job: A Fable for Managers (and Their Employees), by Patrick
Lencioni.
Lencioni is a storyteller. He could be a successful novelist if he cared to be. So
Miserable Job is pleasant to read -- even though it is a fictional case study of a
natural-born manager, Brian Bailey, who has realized that pay, as long as it's
adequate, is not what makes the difference between miserable, unmotivated,
unproductive workers and happy, productive employees who take pride in their
work.
It's all about three things that most managers don't do, though they're obvious
and not very hard. They think they do the first one -- measurement. But
Lencioni's point is that most goals and reports measure things that are largely
out of workers' individual control. Yet if there's no measurement, how can he
tell whether he's doing his job well?
How can people be proud of "a job well done" if they can't figure out whether
they did one?
For instance, a Primary teacher's work can't be measured by attendance --
kids have to come. But (depending on the age of the kids) a good measure
might be how many incidences of inattention there are during a class period.
This is not to identify a "problem child," but for the teachers themselves to
measure how well they are doing.
Besides immeasurement (a word that Lencioni coined), the other signs of a
miserable job are feelings of irrelevancy and anonymity.
A good manager helps workers figure out who they're helping and why their
work makes a positive difference in their lives.
And a good manager makes sure that every worker feels individually known
as a person, and is not just a cog in the machine.
Now ... think about the people that you manage at church. If you're a leader of
an organization, you usually manage teachers or organize group activities
(including meetings). If you're a teacher, you manage the students in your
class during the hour (or two) you have with them. If you're in a bishopric, you
manage other managers.
As a manager, you need to help each person understand how the work they do
is important to someone else -- how they are blessing people's lives. You need
to help them feel known and understood -- by you and by others -- so they feel
themselves to be individually valued, and not just a fully-replaceable cog in a
machine.
And you need to help them find methods of measuring what they do, so they
can know for a fact when they've done it well.
Yes -- that applies to teachers as well as leaders. You need to help your
students measure how well they are doing at learning!
You'll be well-rewarded if you read Lencioni's book, since, like Section 121, it
can apply to many aspects of our lives with other people.
But next week I'm going to tell you the story of a Primary class I taught back in
the late 1970s, and how these very management principles -- though I was not
consciously aware of them at the time -- turned a problem class into a highly
successful one.
Orson Scott Card is the author of the novels Ender's Game, Ender's
Shadow, and Speaker for the Dead, which are widely read by adults and
younger readers, and are increasingly used in schools.
Besides these and other science fiction novels, Card writes contemporary
fantasy (Magic Street,Enchantment,Lost Boys), biblical novels (Stone Tables,Rachel and Leah), the American frontier fantasy series The Tales of Alvin Maker
(beginning with Seventh Son), poetry (An Open Book), and many plays and
scripts.
Card was born in Washington and grew up in California, Arizona, and
Utah. He served a mission for the LDS Church in Brazil in the early 1970s.
Besides his writing, he teaches occasional classes and workshops and directs
plays. He also teaches writing and literature at Southern Virginia University.
Card currently lives in Greensboro, North Carolina, with his wife,
Kristine Allen Card, and their youngest child, Zina Margaret.