Of
all the paintings I have ever seen, if I could have just
one for the rest of my
life, it would be Rue de
Paris, Temps de Pluie/Paris Street, Rainy Day
by Gustave Caillebotte.
Perhaps
because I look at Paris as my second home.
This
hauntingly beautiful cityscape by Caillebotte (1848-1894) belongs to
the Chicago Art Institute, where I have admired it several times and
probably never again will see it. I saw it last when it was borrowed
for an impressive Caillebotte retrospective by the National Gallery,
Washington, D.C.
No
reproduction, with the possible exception of a full-scale computer
generated giclée, can ever do justice to the subtle complexity
of this evocative masterwork. So what you see with this column can be
only a weak hint.
Gustave Caillebotte, Paris Street, Rainy Day, 1877, Chicago Art Institute
(I
make that theoretical exception because several years ago I saw the
trial proof of an 86% size giclée of Arnold Friberg’s
iconic Prayerat Valley Forge,
side by side with the original, and even at that first stage, they
were virtually identical.)
Caillebotte
finished Paris Street, Rainy
Day when he was only 29.
Like Katharine Lane Weems, whom I wrote about last week, he was born
into a rich family and was not dependent upon his art for his
livelihood. In fact, just five years later he quit showing his work.
Gustave’s
grandfather grew his fortune making military uniforms for the Second
Empire armies of Napoleon III. His father enlarged the family wealth
and served as a judge. The father was widowed twice before marrying a
third time and having three more sons, Gustave, René (who died
at 25), and Martial. Martial, like Gustave, did not need to work in
usual pursuits and spent his life writing music. The two brothers
were close.
Gustave
took a degree in law (1868) and obtained his lawyer’s license
two years later. He was also an engineer, excellent yachtsman, avid
gardener — and, of course, a painter. Both sons were passionate
philatelists, and their stamp collections ultimately were acquired by
the British Museum, London.
He
was conscripted for service into the Garde
Nationale Mobile de la Seine
during the Franco-Prussian War. The Garde
became the military wing of an uprising, the Commune, against the
French government that had started and lost the war with the Germans.
This brought an end to the Second Empire, and before the Commune took
control of Paris, Gustave was ready to be a civilian again and pursue
an artistic career. He was 22.
A Soldier, 1881, private collection
The
switch must have been difficult and threatening. Agitating for
radical social changes, the Commune was supported by the working
class, women as well as men. In the Bloody Week, government forces
from Versailles stormed Paris, fought in the streets, and defeated
the disorganized Commune. Terrifying reprisals followed for anyone
associated with the Commune. Karl Marx, from afar, shed tears.
Caillebotte
began studying in the studio of Léon Bonnat (1833-1922), an
academic portraitist. Another Bonnat student was Edgar Degas, who
mentioned Gustave in an 1871 notebook. Degas would introduce him to
his Impressionist friends.
When
he went with his father the next year to Italy, Gustave was struck by
the difference in light (as was Corot a generation earlier) and
painted some of his first landscapes. Gustave, 25, was admitted to
the prestigious Ecole des Beaux-arts, but he seldom attended
classes.
And
then, another year later on Christmas day, Gustave’s father
died. He left his sons with a “belle fortune.” Older
half-brother Alfred, an ordained priest, left with 50,000 pounds
income, became “the richest curé in Paris.”
Gustave and his younger brother Martial inherited most of the
patrimony and could devote the rest of their lives to art (Gustave)
and music (Martial).
It
is incredible that only four years after beginning, though seldom
attending, the Ecole des Beaux-arts Gustave was able to paint
Paris Street, Rainy Day!
Recognition
in France was controlled by the hostile academic juries of the Paris
Salon. In the spring of 1874, the group of artists who soon would be
called, derisively, Impressionists held their first exhibition,
hoping to be recognized by the public.
Claude
Monet recalled six years later, “For some time my friends and I
had been systematically refused by the jury. What to do? It was not
enough to paint. We had to live.” (Marie-Josèphe de
Balanda, Gustave Caillebotte, La Vie, La Technique, Lœuvre
Peint , Lausanne, 1988)
Although
Degas thought Caillebotte would be one of the exhibitors, he was not.
He was there as a supporter. In future manifestations, his paintings
would be included.
The
next year work by Caillebotte, looked upon as an amateur, would be
among the 73 canvases by Berthe Morisot, Claude Monet, Auguste
Renoir, Alfred Sisley, and others put on the Hôtel Drouot
auction block. The sale was a disaster! Caillebotte was the high
bidder — at very low prices — for some of the paintings,
as he sought to support his friends.
The Europe Bridge, 1876, Musée de Petit Palais, Geneva
A
few months later the Salon rejected one of Caillebotte’s own
paintings, thought to be Les Raboteurs de Parquet/The Floor
Scrapers, now recognized as one of the artist’s most
powerful works. This was the final straw that turned the artist
against the Salon. He received a new invitation from Renoir: “We
would be very happy to see you associated with us in this new try.”
Caillebotte
participated in the second Impressionist show with eight canvases,
including two versions of The Floor Scrapers.
The Floor Scrapers, 1875, Musée d’Orsay, Paris
Earlier
in the 19th century when Academism held even a more
vice-like grip on the canons of art, Millet had dared to break away
from classical stuff and glorify peasants at work. The portrayal of
rural rustics became acceptable. The Salon crowd looked upon
Caillebotte’s realistic painting of urban workers as vulgar.
Although
his realist paintings did not employ the divisionist techniques being
discovered by Caillebotte’s friends, he was justifiably
considered an Impressionist, as much of his other work testifies.
Argenteuil Bridge and the Seine River, 1885, Private collection, Lausanne
When
Gustave’s brother René died in 1876, Gustave became
convinced that members of his family died young, and he drew up a
will naming “the stubborn ones” as his beneficiaries.
Renoir was named his executor.
The
next year Gustave procured an apartment for Monet for which he paid
the rent of 175 francs every trimester.
To
enable the Impressionists to have their third exhibition, Caillebotte
rented an appropriate space and then helped Renoir, Monet, and
Pissarro hang the show. A critic saluted this “organizer
without equal, always ready to rent halls, organize expositions, pay
rents, and unceasingly give himself and his wealth.” (ibid)
This
third show marked the high watermark of Impressionist manifestations.
Monet was adamant that no Impressionist who submitted to the Salon
should be allowed to participate. Some of the lesser painters from
the first two shows were excluded, and some of the greatest works by
the participating artists were included. Caillebotte was represented
by six canvases. One of them was Paris Street, Rainy Day.
Emile
Zola, who had greeted prior Impressionist shows with enmity, changed
horses. His approval signaled out Caillebotte.
The
painters decided again, 1877, to try to sell at auction at the Hôtel
Drouot. The highest price realized was 655 francs for Gustave’s
The Floor Scrapers. To help his friends, Caillebotte kept
bidding up their prices.
Caillebotte
moved Monet into a better studio and paid for it himself. Then he
financed the fourth exposition, which Degas titled “Exposition
of a Group of Independent Artists.” Cézanne, Sisley, and
Renoir decided they’d take their chances at the more
prestigious Salon. Morisot was pregnant. Monet was ill, and only the
intervention of Caillebotte with 2,500 francs enabled him to repair
and ship two paintings. Caillebotte himself was represented by 25
works — landscapes, portraits, pastels.
Caillebotte
ceased showing his work in 1882, when he was only 34. He devoted
himself to designing and racing yachts and spent a great deal of time
with his brother Martial and with Renoir. He and Renoir were avid
gardeners.
Oarsmen Rowing on the Yerres River, 1871, private collection
He
died of a pulmonary embolism at 45. The disposition of his estate —
his fabulous collection of art by his friends — is another
compelling story.
His
support of his Impressionist friends was so legendary that this was
the only part of his career that drew much attention for the next 82
years! I had never heard of him until I came across his great
painting in Chicago, and I began challenging my friends to identify
Caillebotte. This neglected master became one of my favorite
painters.
Only
when his family — he never married and had no direct heirs —
began selling his paintings did the world start to take notice. When
the Art Institute of Chicago acquired Paris Street, Rainy Day
in 1964, Americans began to wake up.
Lawrence Jeppson is an art consultant, organizer and curator of art exhibitions, writer, editor
and publisher, lecturer, art historian, and appraiser. He is America's leading authority on
modern, handwoven French tapestries. He is expert on the works of William Henry Clapp, Nat
Leeb, Tsing-fang Chen, and several French artists.
He is founding president of the non-profit Mathieu Matégot Foundation for Contemporary
Tapestry, whose purview encompasses all 20th-century tapestry, an interest that traces back to
1948. For many years he represented the Association des Peintres-Cartonniers de Tapisserie and
Arelis in America.
Through the Smithsonian Institution Traveling Exhibition Service, the American Federation of
Arts, the Museum of Modern Art, and his own Art Circuit Services he has been a contributor to
or organizer of more than 200 art exhibitions in the United States, Canada, Japan, and Taiwan.
He owns AcroEditions, which publishes and/or distributes multiple-original art. He was co-founder and artistic director of Collectors' Investment Fund.
He is the director of the Spring Arts Foundation; Utah Cultural Arts Foundation, and the Fine
Arts Legacy Foundation
Lawrence is an early-in-the-month home teacher, whose beat is by elevator. In addition, he has spent the past six years hosting and promoting reunions of the missionaries who served in the French Mission (France, Belgium, and Switzerland) during the decade after WWII.